NEW: Alleyway pickup! Call the shop (317.773.3770) place your order, then stay in your car and pick up in the alley behind the shop! Click here for more.
CARMACK'S HISTORY
Carmack’s Cigar Shop was established in 1998 by Jeff Carmack with help and support from his father, Dave. Carmack's originally opened a 400-square-foot shop in downtown Indianapolis inside the Hyatt Regency Hotel, a hot spot for celebrities and events at the time. After four years in the Hyatt, they wanted to expand their selection and space, so they closed the downtown store and opened a 3000-square-foot shop in beautiful, historic, downtown Noblesville, IN.​​
​
​For many years Jeff was the youngest cigar shop owner in the US. Over time, he grew the reputation of Carmack's to be one of the best cigar shops in Indiana, filled with a wonderful customer base that enjoyed a wide variety of premium cigars and alcoholic beverages. ​​​
Jeff at the Carmack's 25th Anniversary celebration in 2024
Carmack's is proud to be part of the great community of Noblesville and looks forward to continuing to serve its customers on the square.
​
While the location may have changed, the vision was always to own and operate a cigar shop creating a wonderful atmosphere where folks can come together, buy and appreciate cigars, pipes and their favorite beverage, and enjoy the company of friends.